• Home >
  • Buy >
  • The Final Cut [Remaster] - Pink Floyd (CD 2004) >
  • Search results

The Final Cut [Remaster] - Pink Floyd (CD 2004)

Sort by:
Reviews
  Overlooked and Underrated Classic
Review created: 06/23/08
by:

Pink Floyd is much like any other Progressive Rock group out there: You either love them or you hate them. There's no middle ground. Be it groups like Rush, Yes, Police, King Crimson, each group has its staunch fanbase and no middle-of-the-road fans. This is the last Pink Floyd album to feature Roger Waters in the usual cadre, and you find no shortage of his conceptual influence here: Drawn off some elements of the previous album "The Wall", "The Final Cut" looks at the past, present and future unique elements of war, but goes as far as to illustrate the common thread linking all wars: Power, greed, territoriality, the illusion of glory, the reality of mortality and the eventual futility of it all. If you're used to Waters' lyrics style, you can expect his usual witticisms, which are subtle-yet-piercing and, as always, timed with his trademark precision.

David Gilmour's vocals are largely (If not totally) absent here; It seems the entire album is Waters. Not a good or bad thing, but when one considers the following album "Momentary Lapse Of Reason" and Waters' absence there, some wonder whether this played any part at all in the schism of Waters and Gilmour/Mason. Reason nonwithstanding, the album weathered on to become a classic in its own right with Floydians everywhere. If one is looking for radio staples, you won't find them here; If you're into Floyd, you know how to appreciate Floyd for its own merit, and not for that of the tragically moronic "apply, lather, rinse, repeat" world of Pop Music. Highly recommended.


Review ID: 10000000007681752
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Pink Floyd The Final Cut
Review created: 05/03/08
by:

I dont know why this album does not get much air time, but this is an excellent album by Pink Floyd. It was produced during a time of much turmiol between Roger Waters & David Gilmour. It was, for all intensive purposes, the final cut. This is not an album to brighten your day. It is incredibly depressing to listen to, but the song wrighting is a master piece through out the entire album. I also don't know why Richard Wright was not part of this album, but as Pink Floyd continued their music careers without Roger Waters, Richard rejoined the group to record the follow up album. I bought this album (CD) as it was one of the missing CD's in my Floyd collection. You can almost say this is a Roger Waters album. I believe the other band members were part of it only to fulfill the record contract. There seems to be very little input from other band members. Roger wrote & produced the album . David Gilmour sings only one song (Not Now John) on the entire album. If your a Floyd fan, I highly recommend this CD. If you have any suicidal tendacies, don't buy it. It may take you over the edge.


Review ID: 10000000006955721
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Pink Floyd The Final Cut
Review created: 02/06/08
by:

This is a depressing album but it is very well written. The mood and tempo change is great. Lyrically a very deep and well written album. This album is recorded very good, if you have a high end stereo system it will suck you in. This album is recorded better than any other Floyd album besides maybe Dark Side. Don't just listen once give this album a chance, and definatly read the lyrics while you listen.


Review ID: 10000000005476522
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Artistic quality of a very good album review by Wiz.
Review created: 01/08/08

Everything about this album I enjoy. Had the casette version and lost it.
The only dislike is the album isn't long enough.
Lots of good quality creative art work here.
Very enjoyable album.


Review ID: 10000000005056001
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  A must for any collector
Review created: 05/05/07

This was the album that sealed the fate of Waters-era-Floyd. Roger Waters composed and performed the entire album with the rest of the band acting as backup...something in my opinion, he would have preferred all along. Animosities and bickering between him and Gilmore...and Rogers' own personal demons all come out in this introspective and darkest of all Floyd pieces. In fact, we only hear Gilmore on one song on the entire album.

Quiet, dark, emotionally and philosophical. This should have been a Roger Waters album instead of the last album they would perform as the original core group. I like this album because I always enjoyed the quiet songs from The Wall, but it's an album I can only pull out every now and then because it's SO quiet that it's almost a funeral piece...and I guess in many ways, it was. Rogers left Floyd and it became Gilmore's band...which was still amazingly great...but needed Rogers to balance it with his pain and anger, which is evident in everything he writes.

I recommend this album for hardcore Pink Floyd fans who want to complete their collection...newbies might want to sample it first and then decide if they really like it or not.


Review ID: 10000000003502735
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  the final cut
Review created: 05/04/07
by:

cd in good shape...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................


Review ID: 10000000003495705
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  hard to find..
Review created: 02/03/07
by:

this was worth every penny as it is a difficult album to find. thank you for your prompt delivery of a perfect condition, hard to find album.

cheers.


Review ID: 10000000002853099
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  AWESOME!!!!!
Review created: 12/03/06

It hasn't left my CD player since I've recieved it. It is such a good CD and the love the remastered sound.


Review ID: 10000000002421826
Was this review helpful?
 
Report this review
  Not a happy album!
Review created: 07/16/03
by: matzaballman -- a member of Epinions

Pros:
Great production, <b>Not Now John, The Final Cut</b>, and <b>The Fletcher Memorial Home</b>.

Cons:
Roger Waters <i>whispers</i> too much and there is some filler material.

I must admit, I was very disappointed when I first heard this album. Part of the reason is that before I bought the album, I saw the video for Not Now John on MTV, and I loved the song and was hoping that more of the songs on the album would rock out like that. Well, they don't!! Most of this album sounds like side three of The Wall, in the fact that they're relatively mellow and have the same string arrangements and contain a great deal of whispering from Roger Waters...too much whispering, in my opinion. This album was originally supposed to be called Spare Bricks, a collection of songs...


Review ID: 10000000000229369
  It's Not That Scary
Review created: 09/23/02
by: madcapellan -- a member of Epinions

Pros:
Has quite a few enjoyable moments.

Cons:
Too specific, not enough David Gilmour.

I was afraid of this album. Well, not exactly afraid, but I stayed away from it for quite a while due to all of the negative reviews about it. The general consensus was that it was impossible to get in to. Imagine my surprise when I finally listened to The Final Cut and actually enjoyed it. Unfortunately, there are a few things that keep it from being as good and successful as The Wall. Probably the biggest difference is that The Final Cut is quite a bit more specific than The Wall. Sure they both deal with the death of Waters's father in World War II, but it is not quite as obvious in The...


Review ID: 10000000000229374
  The final cut between Pink and Roger
Review created: 10/23/00
by: fm_hunter -- a member of Epinions

Pros:
This album is a personal masterpiece for Waters; emotionally moving and sonically deep

Cons:
"Not Now John" doesn't really fit here

The final cut, Pink Floyd s last album, is at once their most accessible release while simultaneously alienating many of Floyd s long time fans. While this initially may seem like a contradictory statement, let me explain my reasoning. First of all, don t let the band name of this CD fool you; for all intents and purposes this is a Roger Water s solo album. The beginning of the end for Pink Floyd as a four man band had already begun by the time they began recording The final cut. Thematically, the album is to some extent a continuation of the concept embarked upon on their monumental release,.


Review ID: 10000000000229370
  Roger Water's last Floyd album
Review created: 12/08/00
by: lwinner -- a member of Epinions

Pros:
Deep, cynical, and amazing

Cons:
not as accessible other Floyd albums?

This can either be considered the last album Roger Waters made with Pink Floyd, or the first album of his solo career. The albums name is prophetic, since this album ended up cutting Roger Water s ties with Pink Floyd. My understanding is that the title of the album is an indication that these tracks were cut from The Wall. (I am not 100% on this, but I did read it at a Roger Waters web site at one time.) Also remember that in the early 1990's when the remaining members of Pink Floyd put out a greatest hits album, they left out The Final Cut. This was Water s album, as is evidenced by his...


Review ID: 10000000000229372
  Roger's Final Rant
Review created: 03/27/03
by: nsign -- a member of Epinions

Pros:
Great production, Gilmour's guitar, "Fletcher Memorial Home"

Cons:
Roger Waters writing on his own isn't as good as previous joint efforts

Roger Waters' swansong with Pink Floyd showcases both the best of his lyrical talents, and highlights his weaknesses as a musician. Sporadically a great listen, it inevitably suffers from Waters' ongoing obsession with the death of his father during the second world war, something already well covered on "The Wall". A great lyricist he may be, but wading through another catalogue of Waters' angst does not a great album make. On the plus side, this bitter diatribe against the Falklands War boasts some superb production. I first heard this album while lying in bed after an operation, and...


Review ID: 10000000000229380
Epinions.com ratings are not included in the item's average rating. Links in this review may have been removed.
 
Page 1 of 1

About eBay | Announcements | Security Center | eBay Toolbar | Policies | Government Relations | Site Map | Help
Copyright © 1995-2008 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the eBay User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
eBay official time
Save this search
Name this searchPlease enter a name for your search.Replace an existing search?
Replace this search
Please select a search to replace.
Cancel