as an advid fan of rush and a victim of hurricane katrina i am replacing a complete collection of rush one peice at a time, this one puts me one peice closer.
There isn't much to look forward to here. Not only are the songs either too long ("Marathon", "Mystic Rhythms", "Mission") mostly UN-catchy ("Turn the Page", "Manhattan Project"), the ones that are - the few FM classics "Subdivisions", "Distant Early Warning" and "Closer to the Heart" here are inferior versions. The guitar work by Alex Lifeson at this 1988 British performance is sloppy, his wiry, wurbly sound exactly what you'd hear if he played it underwater. There is no crunch to be found as on the later "Different Stages" live album. Geddy Lee's voice is clearly tired, yelping lines instead of singing them (like on lead off track "The Big Money"). His Wal bass sound lacks any bottom as on earlier Rush albums, rather it's a trebly top end sound. The synthesizers are now digital and sound brighter and "choral", and cannot reproduce the old ominous, analog volume that cut through the wall of sound. Neil Peart's playing reigns, ignore the cheese caused by excessive big band samples). Steer clear of the video companion too. Besides the disappointing sound, the band simply look and behave too silly (Geddy's got the racoon hair cut, Alex forgets his cues), songs are backed up by corny cartoons and pastel pools of light make it painful even to the most ardent fans. Three words for you: EXIT STAGE LEFT.
Thank you for voting. If your vote meets our guidelines, it will be posted within 24 hours.
You cannot vote on the helpfulness of a review you wrote.
Your request cannot be processed at this time. Please try again later.
Stand up and Cheer for A Show of Hands
Review created: 06/22/01
by: jag2112 -- a member of Epinions
Pros: Excellent performances. Strong, powerful music. Good representation of their 80's works.
Cons: A little too polished at times for a live album.
Note: This review is part of a re-writing process I'm going through on my earlier Rush entries. Some of them clearly needed a little more polish so I felt obligated to do so. Rather than delete the original and re-submit a new review, I felt it best to simply modify the original and add a notification of the updated review in PTiemann's Notification System. Thanks for reading... ... The 1980's were drawing to a close as Rush completed the third phase of their career with the release of their third LIVE album - A Show of Hands. This live offering was recorded in various cities during the Hold..